Forum Immigration Poland - Polska


Les forums de l'expatriation en Immigration Poland - Polska: posez vos questions et participez aux discussions d'expatriés.

  Chercher sur tout le site

  Charte utilisateur  -  Aide  -  Règlement  -  Politique de confidentialité

✎ EN Grandfather Polish,my dad doesnt want to be,so how can i be?

Discussion dans 'Immigration Poland - Polska' démarrée par auspol, 3 Novembre 2012.

  1. auspol

    auspol Member

    Inscrit depuis le :
    3 Novembre 2012
    Messages :
    11
    "J'aime" reçus :
    0
    Sexe :
    Masculin
    Pays:
    Australie
    Nationalité:
    Australien (AU)
    Langues:
    English, Sinhala
    Hello all

    Long time reader, first time poster and i promise that im NOT JUST A ONE OFF POSTER TO ASK IF IM ELIGIBLE OR NOT WITHOUT DOING RESEARCH! :D

    My grandfather was Polish, my father was born in Israel in 1953, and they all later naturalized in Australia in the 1960s. Currently waiting for docs to see if my grandfather got to Israel and got israeli citizenship before 1951, but that's a different story.

    I've done a lot of research and I've found a lot of information so my question isn't about whether or not Im eligible for citizenship, its about if I can still get citizenship and a passport without my father doing so,.

    My father is 59 and has no interest in getting me getting him Polish citizenship or a Polish passport. If anything, he is quite against it. Being an immigrant i think he believes Australia is the best place in the world and my grandparents and him went through a lot to get here so why would we want a passport to go back there when we have an Australian one anyway?

    The EU benefits and stuff don't appeal to him even though he does holiday in Europe often. However, he does this on an Australian passport visa free and doesnt want to work there.. well, i think you get the idea.

    Im aware that i have to get his confirmation of Polish citizenship by the Polish government approved and then need to get the birth certs, PESEL number and passport. But lets just say i went ahead and simply got him confirmed but didnt chase up the PESEL number or passport. Would that affect him and his travels to Europe at all? If he decided to go to Poland would he still just enter on his Aussie passport without hassles?

    Basically if he just got confirmed would my siblings and i all be able to get our citizenship confirmed and get Polish passports?


    Just looking for some clarification as to how far through the process we would have to take my dad without making him a passport carrying citizen so that we could become passport carrying citizens!

    Im sure theres other out there who had parents or grandparents that didn't wants to becomes Poles for various reasons. Anything you did to get around it?

    Cheers
     
  2. texkourgan

    texkourgan Addicted member
    Networker Editor

    Inscrit depuis le :
    29 Janvier 2008
    Messages :
    7051
    "J'aime" reçus :
    17
    Sexe :
    Féminin
    Ville:
    Berlin
    Pays:
    Allemagne
    Nationalité:
    Américain (US)
    Langues:
    English, a little Deutsch
    This sounds quite tricky. As an American expat in Europe, I can certainly see how beneficial this would be if you would like to visit, live or work in Europe.

    Have you consulted an immigration attorney? Though this can be expensive, it may be the only way to find real solid information. I know there are several active members of the forum who have dealt with the very difficult Polish ancestry, so hopefully they will have some answers for you. Best of luck, and please be sure to share with us what you find out.
     
    Stop hovering to collapse... Click to collapse... Hover to expand... Cliquer pour déplier...
  3. sophie12

    sophie12 New Member

    Inscrit depuis le :
    24 Juillet 2013
    Messages :
    1
    "J'aime" reçus :
    0
    Sexe :
    Féminin
    Ville:
    sydney
    Pays:
    Australie
    Nationalité:
    Australien (AU)
    Langues:
    english
    Hello,
    I have the same situation
    Did you have any luck finding this out?

    Thanks!
     
  4. rhrh

    rhrh Member

    Inscrit depuis le :
    3 Janvier 2013
    Messages :
    6
    "J'aime" reçus :
    0
    Pays:
    Usa
    Nationalité:
    Américain (US)
    Langues:
    English
    We have a similar situation. Son is looking at Polish citizenship, through his great-grandmother who was born in 1900 in Dobromil, in southeast Poland, and left Poland in 1921. She was never naturalized in the US.

    My son is the only one interested in Polish citizenship, my father is uninterested and would not want to go through the "work", and I for specific reasons do not want to get it.

    Does it matter at all? Or if my son can get his Polish citizenship without us getting ours, if we travel to Poland, and it was already proven that my son is indeed a citizen by blood and carries a Polish passport, we could be asked to manifest our Polish citizenship?

    I'm also in the dark about whether he could use his US and Polish passports at various times, or would he have to give the US passport up?

    Thank you for any answers you can give. It looks to me on the surface that it does not matter if the "links" get their citizenship or not, but they might be treated as Polish citizens if they must be for the person manifesting to get theirs?
     
  5. auspol

    auspol Member

    Inscrit depuis le :
    3 Novembre 2012
    Messages :
    11
    "J'aime" reçus :
    0
    Sexe :
    Masculin
    Pays:
    Australie
    Nationalité:
    Australien (AU)
    Langues:
    English, Sinhala
    Hey Sophie,

    Sorry for the late reply. After finally getting alll the documents needed to submit the application, i was unable to get Polish citizenship.

    This is because my grandfather registered/signed up for the Israeli army reserves in 1950. If the military records show that he signed up for it before 1951, even though it was mandatory and even if he never even picked up a gun, then he automatically lost Polish citizenship.

    I missed out by about 3 months!!

    I would be happy to tell you how i went about getting all the docs if you like. Its much easier if you still have family in Israel to help or if you speak hebrew.
     
  6. auspol

    auspol Member

    Inscrit depuis le :
    3 Novembre 2012
    Messages :
    11
    "J'aime" reçus :
    0
    Sexe :
    Masculin
    Pays:
    Australie
    Nationalité:
    Australien (AU)
    Langues:
    English, Sinhala
    If you could tell me more about how the grandparent is related to you then i should be able to give you a better opinion.

    Was it your grandmother who was Polish?
    Is your grandfather also polish?
    Were your parents born in America or Poland?
     
  7. richasis

    richasis Member

    Inscrit depuis le :
    13 Février 2009
    Messages :
    14
    "J'aime" reçus :
    0
    Pays:
    Pologne
    Nationalité:
    Américain (US)
    Langues:
    English
    As for me, I DID receive my Passport/PESEL with ONLY my mother's Confirmation.

    Of course, as in OP's case, other factors come into play; but yes, this is possible.
     
Chargement...
Sujets similaires Forum Date
✎ EN Grandfather who served in a foreign army Immigration Poland - Polska 4 Juillet 2015
✎ EN Tracking down Grandfather's Passport (hopefully) Immigration Poland - Polska 4 Juillet 2011
✎ EN Translating Documents For Polish Citizenship Immigration Poland - Polska 9 Août 2020
✎ EN Issues with Confirmation of Polish Citizenship + Attorney Immigration Poland - Polska 31 Août 2019
✎ EN Polish Citizenship (Mother Was Born In Poland 1921) Immigration Poland - Polska 24 Septembre 2018

Partager cette page